Talking to plants may help them grow faster, but there is no definitive evidence that a gift of gab will turn you into a green thumb. Ideal conditions for growth have more to do with temperature than talk. While there hasn’t been enough evidence to prove that talking to plants helps them grow, there is good reason to believe that music does help plants grow. The TV show MythBusters did an experiment involving plants and found that at 70 decibels, there was increased growth.
The idea that talking to plants helps them grow is not a modern notion. Experts believe this theory probably dates back to a book from 1848, in which German professor Gustav Fechner suggested plants might be. There is no consistent scientific evidence that talking or singing to plants helps them grow better or produce more fruit. Some studies have shown an effect on plants from music.
There are several theories as to why scientists believe talking may help plants grow. One theory is that the carbon dioxide we breath on the plants while talking to them is due to the vibrations that come from their higher pitch tones than men. Research shows that speaking nicely to plants will support their growth, whereas yelling at them won’t.
In a MythBusters experiment involving plants, it was found that mellow music can actually encourage plant growth. While there is no definitive evidence that a gift of gab will turn you into a green thumb, it is known that plants respond to noise. In studies performed by the Royal Horticultural Society and others, researchers have found that talking to plants really can help them grow faster. However, it will affect the person doing it, leading to more neglectful behavior and rougher handling.
📹 Student’s Science Project Experiments On Bullying Plants
CBS2’s Ali Bauman has the latest on a unique science project that looked at the effect bullying a plant has on its life.
Is it okay to talk to plants?
Dr Dominique Hes, a biophilia expert and lead researcher at Horticulture Innovation Australia’s Plant Life Balance, suggests that plants respond better to vibrations and volume than words. Plants react favorably to low levels of vibrations, with 115-250hz being ideal. Smithsonian and Nasa studies show that mild vibrations increase growth in plants, while harsher vibrations have a negative effect. Vibrations improve communication and photosynthesis, which improves growth and the ability to fight infection. This suggests that plants are happy with their surroundings.
What happens if you talk bad to a plant?
The YouHadMeAtGardening project conducted a study to answer the question of why it’s beneficial to talk to plants. They exposed three pots of seeds to different speeches, one of which was Martin Luther King’s “I have a dream” speech and the other to Adolf Hitler’s “Hitler’s” speech. The results showed that the plants responded differently to the speeches, with the “I have a dream” pot showing a better response.
Dr. Emoto’s Rice Experiment also showed that plants respond differently to different words. The first bowl, exposed to positive words, retained a pleasant aroma, while the second bowl turned black after being called “idiot” daily. The third bowl, ignored for a month, started to rot.
Despite the numerous attempts to prove the impact of negative or positive words on our environment, studies are still being conducted and becoming more reliable. This led to the creation of an experiment to answer the question of why it’s beneficial to talk to plants.
Do plants like to be touched?
Fresh indoor plants require careful care and attention, but most plants do not like being touched. This preference depends on the plant, with some plants not minding being touched near as much as others. It is important to understand what plants do and don’t like being touched before choosing a house plant.
Plants don’t die when touched, but it is not advisable. They have sensitive leaves that need to sense sunlight, movement in the air, and weather, and human touch is generally harsh for these leaves. Therefore, it is essential to be cautious when handling plants to ensure their safety and well-being.
Do plants grow worse if you yell at them?
Research indicates that speaking politely to plants supports their growth, while yelling at them doesn’t. This may be due to vibrations and volume, as plants react favorably to low levels of vibrations. The Smithsonian and NASA have found that mild vibrations improve communication and photosynthesis, which in turn improves their growth and ability to fight infection. This makes plants happy and healthy.
Caring for plants can also make you happier, as it improves communication and photosynthesis. Jolly Lane Greenhouse offers a variety of houseplants, including popular plants like Aloe Vera and English Ivy, succulents, tropical plants like Hibiscus and Bromeliads, and fruit trees.
Are loud noises bad for plants?
A study reveals that some plants perform worse in noisy areas, while others perform better depending on the changes in their surrounding creatures. The long-lasting effects can be far-reaching, especially for trees, which take decades to grow from seedlings into adults. The findings are likely applicable to any ecosystem where animals are affected by noise. Most literature on noise impacts has focused on a single species’ communication issues.
Does speaking to a plant help it grow?
Richard Marini, Ph. D., a professor and head of horticulture at the College of Agricultural Sciences, suggests that the best way to help plants grow is by providing them with light, water, and mineral nutrition. While sound may stimulate plant growth, there is no definitive evidence that a gift of gab will turn you into a green thumb. The ideal conditions for growth are more related to temperature than talk.
Does noise have an effect on plant growth?
The study revealed that exposure to loud, high-frequency sound tones enhanced the rate of plant sprouting and growth, whereas random noise had the opposite effect.
Does sound affect plant growth?
Plants have a unique preference for music, with some genres promoting growth and others damaging. Roses, for instance, prefer violin music. Classical or jazz music can increase growth in plants, while harsh metal music can induce stress. Botanists, like Devendra Vanol of the Institute of Integrated Study and Research in Biotechnology and Allied Sciences in India, believe that plants can distinguish between different types of sound, including music genres, nature sounds, and traffic noise. This could be advantageous for plants to learn about their environment.
Reda Hassanien of China Agricultural University in Beijing found that sound waves significantly increased the yield of sweet pepper, cucumber, tomato, spinach, cotton, rice, and wheat. Additionally, sound treatment reduced pests such as spider mites, aphids, gray mold, late blight, and virus diseases in tomatoes. More studies are needed to understand how this works and what it could teach us about plants.
Do plants react to your voice?
Plant growth is influenced by sound, with studies showing that at an average human conversational tone (70 decibels), plants produce more. This not only benefits plants but also provides a psychological boost, as spending time with and around plants is calming and promotes good mental and physical health. A study by the Royal Horticultural Society showed that reading to tomato plants daily led to larger plants and more pronounced female voices. This theory dates back to 1848 when a German professor published “The Soul Life of Plants”, which suggested that plants benefit from human conversation.
The popular TV show MythBusters also conducted an experiment to determine if plant growth was influenced by sound, with promising results. While this theory is not strictly scientific, it does suggest the potential benefits of talking to plants.
Do plants react to insults?
A 30-day initiative conducted by IKEA in the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Egypt, and Oman has demonstrated that compliments can have a substantial effect on a plant’s health and vitality, whereas insults can cause it to wither and droop. Furthermore, the initiative has facilitated an understanding of the impact of words among children and their families.
Do plants respond to human emotions?
Plants lack a central nervous system but can process external information and respond to it. They remember stimuli and communicate with other plants about them. Animals have neurons that transmit sensory feelings to the brain, while plants have memories that help avoid future pain. In humans, the brain sends a message back to the source of negative feelings, causing them to react to avoid further pain. Animals like humans have memories that do not trigger adrenaline when the memory of previous injuries returns.
📹 Talking Plants Mini-Myth
Do plants grow better with sweet talk and classical music? Maybe yelling and constant heavy metal music does the trick. Stream …
When they are talking and screaming at the plants they are enhancing the C02 that is in the greenhouse, which will make the plants perform better. I am unsure whether they had as much interaction with the plants that had music played to them, but I feel it should have been more controlled, like C02 monitors, automated watering systems, adequate ventilation and cameras inside the music green houses. Either way its a highly interesting subject.
Makes sense! If you take a look at the famous rice experiment, then you know that water (which is what you are talking to) is the worst if you ignore it. It is normal that the 2 you guys talked to are not to different, it should be love vs hate, but yelling YEAAAAH doesn’t really means hate, just hard encouragement. Nice one doh, hope to see a do-over for conclusive evidence!